MOLDOVA 2021Torture and other ill-treatment persisted. Impunity for grave past abuses by law enforcement agencies remained endemic. Concerns over unfair trials continued. Judicial oversight of surveillance and approval of pretrial detention was reported to be weak. Little progress was made in addressing domestic violence. In the breakaway Transdniestria region critics of the de facto authorities faced prosecution and concerns were raised about the right to education.
BackgroundA stand-off between the President and parliament following the Prime Minister’s resignation came to an end with early parliamentary elections in July, resulting in the formation of the first non-coalition government since 2009. In September parliament voted to appoint a new national human rights Ombudsperson, amid concern in some quarters that her role as legal adviser to Maia Sandu in the 2020 presidential elections may create a potential conflict of interest. The Covid-19 pandemic continued to affect the economy, resulting in falling standards of living for many, although government economists predicted a return to growth by the end of the year. Free Covid-19 vaccination was made widely available, with a choice of vaccines, and promoted during vaccination marathons in the capital, Chisinau, and elsewhere. The uptake of free Western-supplied vaccines in the breakaway Transdniestria region was lukewarm, with many residents preferring the Russian-produced Sputnik vaccine or resisting vaccination altogether.
Torture and other ill-treatmentNo visible progress was made in addressing torture and other ill-treatment. Overcrowding, unsanitary and otherwise inadequate detention conditions were regularly reported in adult, juvenile and mixed penitentiary institutions. The National Ombudsperson for Children’s Rights reported further adverse effects of the Covid-19 pandemic on conditions for minors in detention, with those from socially disadvantaged families particularly affected. Complaints of poor diagnostics and health provisions were commonplace, while medical staff remained part of penitentiary rather than health authorities. A riot at the Brănești penitentiary institution, on 5 February, highlighted the issue of an informal hierarchy and inter-prisoner violence, which the authorities chronically failed to address.
ImpunityImpunity for major past human rights violations by members of law enforcement agencies, including mass torture and other ill-treatment of peaceful protesters in 2009, remained endemic. No progress was reported in the case of the abduction and forcible return of seven Turkish nationals by Moldovan security services in 2018, further to the limited investigation and a single conviction and non-custodial sentence in 2020. In March, the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers considered implementation of the European Court of Human Right’s decision in this case (Ozdil and Others v. Republic of Moldova) and “firmly reiterated” the need to ensure effective oversight and accountability of the security services and “regretted the authorities’ lack of a response” to its previous call. In October, Moldova submitted its Updated Action Plan on the judgment which committed it to review past judicial decisions and adopt legislation intended to increase the accountability of its security services.
Right to a fair trialConcerns over unfair trials persisted. No progress was reported in the 38 criminal cases in which the Prosecutor General had acknowledged political motivation and promised a review in 2020. In none was the conviction quashed or criminal proceedings terminated. In the most high-profile case, Veaceslav Platon, freed in 2020 pending a new investigation and retrial, left Moldova in July. The Prosecutor General was widely blamed for him leaving the country but brushed aside criticism as “political interference” with his work. The handling of these cases in light of persistent concerns over selective justice again exposed the weaknesses of the criminal justice system, its vulnerability to political interference and the need for reform.
Right to privacyNGOs and defence lawyers continued to express concern that judicial review of law enforcement agencies’ requests for wiretapping of private communications and for placing criminal suspects in pretrial detention was insufficiently probing, and resulted in near-total approval. Safeguards envisaged in national law, such as the persons being wiretapped being compulsorily informed, were not observed. At a press conference on 4 October, the Prosecutor General accused a former colleague and several NGOs of plotting to unseat him, and claimed he had seen the content of their mobile communications. He was arrested the following day on several charges, including abuse of authority.
Gender-based violenceOn 14 October parliament approved ratification of the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (Istanbul Convention), which Moldova signed in 2017. Little tangible progress was made, however, in addressing domestic violence, which predominantly affected women.
Freedom of expressionCritics of the de facto authorities faced criminal prosecution. In July, pensioner Mikhail Yermuraki was convicted of “insulting the President” and fined the equivalent of US$600. Two other charges against him, “denying the positive role of Russian peacekeepers” and “inciting national, racial, religious hatred”, were dropped. In the same month, activist Gennadiy Chorba was sentenced to three years and three months’ imprisonment, for the same offence of insulting the President as well as on charges of “extremism” in connection with a peaceful picket a year earlier which he had attended. The de facto authorities accused him of inciting people to protest, as well as of making derogatory comments about medical personnel during the pandemic.
Right to educationIn August, the de facto Transdniestrian authorities refused to reregister the Lucian Blaga Theoretical High School, the only Romanian-language school in the regional capital, Tiraspol, and suspended its operations for at least three months. The reasons were not reported. The de facto authorities reversed the decision to suspend the school in the same month, after intervention by the OSCE and other international partners.
Amnesty International’s Annual State of the World Report Slams Governments, Including the U.S., for Global Assault on Freedoms
February 22, 2016
Your rights in jeopardy, global assault on freedoms, warns Amnesty International
February 18, 2016 – State of the World 2015
Amnesty International State of the World 2015-2016
February 18, 2016 – Annual Report
State of the World 2014/2015
February 25, 2015
Annual Report: Moldova 2013
May 21, 2013
Moldovan Laws Must be Reformed to Combat Discrimination
September 10, 2012
Annual Report: Moldova 2010
March 19, 2011