Death Penalty and Innocence

Death Penalty and Innocence

Since 1973, over 130 people have been released from death rows throughout the country due to evidence of their wrongful convictions. In 2003 alone, 10 wrongfully convicted defendants were released from death row.

Governor Ryan
"I cannot support a system which, in its administration, has proven so fraught with error and has come so close to the ultimate nightmare, the state's taking of innocent life... Until I can be sure that everyone sentenced to death in Illinois is truly guilty, until I can be sure with moral certainty that no innocent man or woman is facing a lethal injection, no one will meet that fate."

--Governor George Ryan of Illinois, January 2000, in declaring a moratorium on executions in his state, after the 13th Illinois death row inmate had been released from prison due to wrongful conviction. In the same time period, 12 others had been executed. (photo © AFP) 

Examples of wrongful convictions:

Alabama: Daniel Wade Moore, acquitted in 2009
  • When Moore was originally found guilty for murder and sexual assault of Karen Tipton in 2002 he was sentenced to death by the judge overruling the jury's original consensus.  However, he was acquitted in 2009 when 256 pages of withheld evidence were finally revealed.    

Texas: Anthony Graves, charges dismissed in 2010 
  • Graves was convicted in 1994 of assisting Robert Carter in multiple murders in 1992.  There was no physical evidence linking Graves to the crimes, and his conviction relied on Carter's testimony that Graves was his accomplice, a claim Carter later recanted.  In 2006 it was found that prosecuters elicited false statements and withheld testimony that could have influenced the jurors.  A special prosecutor hired to re-examine the case said "we found not one piece of credible evidence that links Anthony Graves to the commission of this capital murder.  He is an innocent man." 

Florida: Seth Penalver, acquitted in 2012
  • Penalver was arrested in 1994 for the brutal murder of three individuals.  There was no physical evidence linking him to the murder; the only "evidence" police had was a poor-quality video in which the murderer's face could not be seen.  He remained in custody until 2012 when the jury at his most recent trial acquitted him of all charges.

Factors leading to wrongful convictions include:

  • Inadequate legal representation
  • Police and prosecutorial misconduct
  • Perjured testimony and mistaken eyewitness testimony
  • Racial prejudice
  • Jailhouse "snitch" testimony
  • Suppression and/or misinterpretation of mitigating evidence
  • Community/political pressure to solve a case