Whom would you suspect of killing Berta Cáceres?

March 9, 2016


“Defending human rights in Honduras is a crime. They are criminalizing the right to our [indigenous] identity and sense of self.”
-Berta Cáceres, 2013

Gunmen brutally murdered Berta Cáceres, award-winning leader of the Council of Indigenous and Popular Organizations of Honduras (COPINH), in La Esperanza, Honduras on March 3, 2016. Almost immediately, the Honduran authorities jumped to the conclusion that she must have been killed in a robbery.

They also stopped Gustavo Castro Soto, a Mexican human rights defender who was staying with Cáceres and who was also injured in the attack, from leaving the country. He has already provided testimony about the crime. He now fears for his safety should he be returned to the area in which he and Cáceres were attacked. Furthermore, Amnesty International is concerned that Castro Soto’s rights to due process may be violated and that he is not receiving full and prompt information about the status of the investigation.

Amnesty International has documented that Berta Cáceres has received death threats related to her human rights activism since at least 1997. In 2013, Amnesty reported that Cáceres and fellow indigenous leaders were receiving death threats related to their opposition to a hydroelectric dam that would displace hundreds of indigenous (Lenca) families. One of those leaders, Tomás Garcia, was shot and killed by Honduran Army troops during a protest against the dam. The Honduran government then filed charges against Cáceres and two other indigenous leaders. They were accused of inciting usurpation, coercion, and damages against the company behind the Rio Blanco dam project. Amnesty International reported that they had been exercising their right to freedom of expression against building the dam. The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights recognized imminent risk Berta Cáceres was facing and ordered the Honduran authorities to provide protection for her, which she did not have at the time she was murdered.

People attend the funeral of murdered indigenous activist Berta Caceres, in La Esperanza, 200 km northwest of Tegucigalpa, on March 5, 2016. Honduran indigenous activist Berta Caceres, a renowned environmentalist whose family has labeled her killing an assassination, was shot dead on March 3 at her home in La Esperanza. Caceres rose to prominence for leading the indigenous Lenca people in a struggle against a hydroelectric dam project that would have flooded large areas of native lands and cut off water supplies to hundreds.  AFP PHOTO / ORLANDO SIERRA / AFP / ORLANDO SIERRA        (Photo credit should read ORLANDO SIERRA/AFP/Getty Images)
People attend the funeral of murdered indigenous activist Berta Caceres, in La Esperanza, 200 km northwest of Tegucigalpa, on March 5, 2016. (ORLANDO SIERRA/AFP/Getty Images)

Cáceres continued to be subject to threats and harassment as she refused to abandon the movement against construction of the dam. In this context, whom would you suspect of murdering Berta Cáceres?

Common criminals who just happened to rob the house in which she was staying?

A fellow human rights activist who was also injured in the attack?

The Honduran authorities should determine who has been behind the threats against Berta Cáceres and her fellow activists and conduct and independent investigation to determine if they had carried out their threats by killing her. Indeed, the Honduran authorities should have identified and punished the individuals and groups threatening Cáceres before she was killed. Their failure to do so made this murder, in the words of Amnesty International Americas Director Erika Guevara-Rosas, into “a tragedy waiting to happen.”

Mexican human rights defender Gustavo Castro Soto, the sole witness to the murder of Indigenous leader Berta Cáceres, fears for his safety in Honduras, and wants to go back to his home in Mexico. Please take action and tell the Honduran authorities to protect the rights and safety of Gustavo Castro Soto, and allow him to return to his country.